SearchDemocracy LinksMember's Off-site Blogs |
Palestinians will be free...
In his 2026 Manning Clark Lecture, George Browning challenges the religious narratives used to justify violence against Palestinians and offers a radically different vision of shared rights, freedom and humanity. Amalek or Freude: Israel and the world must choose
So far, Australian politicians and most media outlets have, knowingly or unknowingly, backed Amalek, meaning diplomacy, dialogue and a search for a genuine solution has no genuine international support. The recent story of the Middle East is well known and needs little amplification. Such is the horror unleashed by Israel that the International Criminal Court issued an arrest warrant for Benjamin Netanyahu on 21 November 2024. According to the ICC, there are reasonable grounds to believe he bears criminal responsibility for several alleged offences committed during the Gaza conflict between 8 October 2023 and 20 May 2024. That a Claytons ‘Board of Peace’ was launched under President Donald Trump as part of a Gaza peace initiative is also well known. The board’s ambition was not a just restoration, but a capitalist utopia in which various entities were invited to invest. The current situation in Gaza is catastrophic. The brutality of 7 October 2023 deserves unequivocal condemnation, but response out of decades of isolation and deprivation needs to be understood. It has suited Netanyahu to keep Palestine politically inept. The natural leader, Marwan Barghouti, has been kept in gaol for 24.5 years, and it appears the existence of Hamas was enabled by Netanyahu, to prevent Fatah (the PA) from exercising unified leadership. Is there a way forward? What lens can we use to move beyond the daily occurrences of inhumanity to a future which provides security and prosperity for Israelis and Palestinians alike? The lens I would like to use is the contrasting positions of Amalek and Freude Benjamin Netanyahu invoked Amalek in his incursion into Gaza following 7 October and he has recently invoked Amalek in relation to his desired obliteration of Iran: “We remember and we act”. What is he invoking? Let us turn first to Deuteronomy 25:17–19. Remember what Amalek did to you on your journey out of Egypt, how he attacked you on the way, when you were faint and weary, and struck down all who lagged behind you; he did not fear God. Therefore, when the Lord your God has given you rest from all your enemies on every hand, in the land your God is giving you as an inheritance to possess, you shall blot out the remembrance of Amalek from under heaven; do not forget. This injunction became a task, if not a condition for Saul, when he was anointed the first king. Samuel said to Saul, the Lord sent me to anoint you king over his people Israel; now therefore listen to the words of the Lord. “Thus says the Lord of hosts, I will punish the Amalekites for what they did in opposing the Israelites when they came up out of Egypt. Now go and attack Amalek and utterly destroy all that they have; do not spare them, but kill both man and woman, child and infant, ox and sheep, camel and donkey”. Saul took up the fight against the Amalekites, but did not follow instructions, taking to himself Amalekite livestock and produce as bounty. For this failure he was to lose the kingdom in favour of David. Seeing Israel’s future through the Amalekite lens, confirms Israeli assumptions. It confirms the right-wing settler view held by many, especially Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich, that Palestinians have stolen their land. Thus, they can be summarily removed or killed. They are dross. It confirms the assumption that Israel is always the victim and because it is the victim its actions are justified. Groups as diverse as ’the lobby’, Christian Zionists, the Murdoch press, News 24, and NSW Premier Chris Minns all insist Israel is the victim. In 1947 the UN proposed the partitioning of Palestine into what would ultimately become two states Israel and Palestine on roughly a 50–50 basis. Much later, the 1967 borders which were accepted by both sides as a peace plan in the Oslo agreement signed at Camp David, allocate Israel 72 per cent and Palestine 28 per cent of the original Palestine. As we all know, illegal settlements now disenfranchise much of the remaining 28 per cent, corralling Palestinians into enclaves. Israel is not the victim, and those who protest their houses being destroyed, their vineyards burnt, and their lives impoverished are not terrorists. This lens also informs the Israeli definition of antisemitism. Jillian Segal insists that bodies from governments to political parties, to universities and unions, all adopt the IHRA definition of antisemitism. The definition itself may appear innocuous, but the examples it provides clearly define criticism of Israel’s government and its policies as antisemitic. Why this definition? That this definition is now to be part of our school curriculum is outrageous. Why has Segal so much influence amongst the political elite? Through the Amalek lens, Israel’s actions are justified and therefore criticism of them is anti-Jewish and consequently antisemitic. This definition has become a weapon. The Amalek lens also undergirds Christian Zionism. Misconstrued belief that God’s end times are connected to Israel’s ‘rightful’, indeed destined, occupation of all the land and the rebuilding of the temple on the site now occupied by the al-Aqsa mosque. It would take too long to explain the enormity of this nonsense and its cost politically, militarily and in terms of human suffering. It is the very antithesis of the Christian Way. Most troublingly, the Amalek lens enables an end-times messianic, apocalyptic, interpretation of world events, and for those committed to such a vision, incentive to hurry such an end through participation in chaos and violence. US officers are complaining their commanders have urged them to tell their soldiers that “their fight is part of God’s divine plan – the bloodier the better”. Israel’s confrontation with Iran, again through the Amalek lens, has reaped untold disaster, not simply on Iran, but on neighbouring Arab nations, indeed upon the whole globe. It is universally accepted that the impetus for this war came from Netanyahu, who was able to yoke Trump’s vanity, his desire for oil, and his insatiable appetite for parading himself as a strong winner, to the Israeli cause. It should surprise no one that Pete Hegseth is amongst the most extreme upholders of Christian Zionism. It is the Amalek lens that is so far preventing the United Arab List from being appropriately included in Knesset power sharing. You cannot enter an alliance with those who have no right to be there. Israel must decide between democracy and ethnic exclusion. Australia must stop referring to Israel as a democracy that shares our values. It is past time that the world community and the Australian government, put an end to this Israeli, Zionist, political, indulgence, and its misuse of a deep religious, cultural history. Palestinians are paying a terrible price for a corrupted interpretation of both history and theology. Following Netanyahu’s Iran war, Arab neighbours, indeed the whole globe, is paying a price. Sanctions, boycotts and disinvestments must be applied. If we do not have the courage to do this for moral reasons, supporting and protecting Palestinians, then do it for self-interest’s sake. Every Australian is paying a very high price for Israel’s false sense of victimhood and its inability to take its place with and among those who rightfully live with them in what has for a long time been called, the Holy Land. Now for a different lens – Freude In 1993 the Maastricht Treaty came into effect marking the founding of the European Union. This union was possible because of shared values and shared humanity. On significant occasions the EU’s official anthem is played; it is based on the iconic fourth movement of Beethoven’s Symphony No. 9 in D minor – the Ode to Joy. Its objective is to celebrate the values member states share and their unity in diversity. It expresses the ideals of a united Europe: freedom, peace and solidarity. Into this fourth movement Beethoven sets the text of Friedrich Schiller’s poem An die Freude (Ode to Joy). Thy charms bind again, what fashion strictly divides, all men become brothers, where thy gentle wing dwells. The poem describes joy not as the product of a particular set of circumstances, but as a catalyst of those circumstances, particularly the ‘brotherhood of humanity’. The Old Testament testifies to joy as a mark of Jewishness. Nehemiah asserts “The joy of the Lord is your strength.” Joy is the outcome of knowing God’s presence, of finding that abundance is always on offer even when stricture and difficulty are all around. It appears Zionism has stripped those who are committed to it of their Jewishness. What kind of joy exists in the lives of settlers rampaging through Palestinian villages, harassing Palestinian children and elderly alike? What joy is there in the minds of those who work checkpoints for no reason other than to harass? What joy does an IDF soldier have who has just shot a Palestinian child or prevented a Palestinian mother from seeing her child? I have personally witnessed this joylessness. Crossing from Jordan into Israel over the King Hussein / Allenby Bridge, is not to experience joy! Having a gun pointed at you on the outskirts of Nablus is not a joyful experience! Sitting in the children’s court watching shackled Palestinian children being marched in with no legal counsel, words spoken in Hebrew and documents forced to sign in Hebrew, is not a joyful experience. One can only imagine an Israeli future marked by empty individual Israeli souls, combining to make a nation without a soul. A nation abandoned even by US citizens for whom the actions of Israel have become intolerable. It need not be this way. The way forward is at the heart of Judaism. It was no less than the chief rabbi of Britain, the late Lord Jonathan Sacks, who reminded me that any special covenant Judaism celebrates with God must be set within the universal covenant of the creation narrative in which God’s blessing is equally upon the whole created order. Israel’s vocation, the same as the vocation of any people of faith, is to be a conduit of that universal blessing. Every human is unique, special, but conversely every human being is no more and no less than a partaker in the life of all humanity. Israel can and should be the initiator of the Middle East’s own version of the Maastricht Treaty. The national boundaries of the Middle East result from the self-interest of Britain and France following World War I. Commonality across those boundaries is considerable and should be celebrated. Palestinians and Israelis have much to offer one another. When I visited Bassam Tamimi and his daughter Ahed in his village of Nabi Salih in area C of the West Bank, he told me he had no desire to live in a distinctively Palestinian state, he wants to live freely in land shared by Israelis and Palestinians, same rights, same opportunities, same freedom to practise diversity of religion and culture. That is what the chant “from the river to the sea Palestinians shall be free”, is all about. It is outrageous that proclaiming this vision in some parts of Australia is a criminal offence. At present Palestinians are not free anywhere, not even as 20 per cent citizens of Israel proper. The world must choose which lens informs our action, Amalek – grievance, fear, and endless violence or Freude – respect, trust, mutuality, joy, and shared prosperity. In keeping with a charter of human rights Palestinians should be free; in their freedom they cease being stereotyped as terrorists, they are fellow citizens. Let me finish by Crying From the River to the Sea, Palestinians will be free. https://pearlsandirritations.com/post/2026/11/amalek-or-freude-israel-and-the-world-must-choose/
PLEASE VISIT: YOURDEMOCRACY.NET RECORDS HISTORY AS IT SHOULD BE — NOT AS THE WESTERN MEDIA WRONGLY REPORTS IT — SINCE 2005. Gus Leonisky POLITICAL CARTOONIST SINCE 1951. RABID ATHEIST. WELCOME TO THIS INSANE WORLD….
SEE: managing the stylistic delusions of humankind...The "sacred texts" in ALL religions have been dictated by men... GOD is an invention of designed wishes to give credence to robbery and murder of other tribes. "Sacred texs" are weapons of war. They are also cutural nooses designed to make populations live in fear and in the peudo-comfort of blame.
|
User login |
Recent comments
1 hour 14 min ago
4 hours 3 min ago
4 hours 27 min ago
20 hours 19 min ago
1 day 3 hours ago
1 day 4 hours ago
1 day 16 hours ago
1 day 16 hours ago
1 day 16 hours ago
2 days 2 min ago