Monday 29th of April 2024

terminal .....

terminal .....

From a political perspective, all that matters in the Craig Thomson saga is whether the MP is eligible to remain in Parliament.

If Labor had a 10-seat majority, the Coalition would not be showing much interest at all in the case.

But Labor has a one-seat margin and if Thomson were drummed out, then the government would most likely fall as it could not, in the current climate, conceivably hold his Central Coast seat of Dobell in a by-election.

But to be drummed out, an MP must be convicted of an indictable offence that carries a penalty of a year or more in jail.

As of now, Thomson has not even been charged with anything. He has not even been officially accused of a criminal offence.

Fair Work Australia says it found 181 contraventions which occurred during the period Thomson was at the helm of the Health Services Union, before his move to Federal Parliament.

Of these, 76 were minor administrative breaches which do not warrant further action or penalty. The other 105, says FWA, are breaches of the Workplace Relations Act which it will refer to the Federal Court for civil action. The maximum penalty for each is a fine.

FWA says it is not qualified to judge whether any of these breaches may also constitute criminal activity so it has sent the whole report to the DPP, rather than the police, to make that determination.

For Labor - and Thomson - the best result yesterday would have been for FWA to make its findings and, as it did when it handed down a report into the HSU's Victorian East branch a month ago, decide none of the breaches warranted referral to the DPP.

Notwithstanding the two ongoing police investigations in NSW and Victoria, this would have resolved the matter, insofar as it would have eliminated the prospect of criminal charges against Thomson emanating from the Fair Work Australia process.

However, referral to the DPP keeps the issue alive as a distraction and an embarrassment for federal Labor and keeps alive the prospect that criminal charges may result.

Thus, the nightmare continues.

If criminal charges do emerge, given the glacial pace of the legal system, it is unlikely there would be an outcome before the federal election is due by the spring of next year.

In its bones, the Opposition knows this, so its tactic is to try and muster moral outrage over the concept of Julia Gillard's government depending on an MP who is under investigation by the DPP.

It hopes to create enough pressure that four independent MPs support it in moving a no-confidence motion against the government, which would end its tenure.

The shadow attorney-general, George Brandis, has demanded Thomson should at least move to the cross benches.

Apart from the fact Thomson must be presumed innocent until proved otherwise, the biggest impediment to the Coalition argument is the fact Tony Abbott stood by and accepted the vote last year of his own Senator, Mary Jo Fisher, after she had been actually charged with theft and assault.

The alleged offences are not the same but the principle is.

Charges or not, the Thomson nightmare continues for Labor

 

the bleedin' obvious .....

from Crikey .....

Although almost everyone in the Canberra media establishment hates to acknowledge it, the most incisive political commentary in Australia invariably doesn't come from one of their own - it is penned by their enemy No.1.

Here's a bit of what he had to say on the op-ed page of today's Australian Financial Review:

"In theory, the work of a union official should be a humbling task, representing the interests of employees who are powerless to represent themselves. In practice, however, union chiefs are arrogant types, perceiving themselves as above the laws of the industrial system.

"This conceitedness is a product of their dual role within the labour movement. Not only do they run union offices, they also control factional numbers inside the ALP.

"This is an intoxicating power, determining the selection of Labor candidates and even the nation's leadership.

"The tragedy for progressive politics is that there are scores of Craig Thomsons across the labour movement. He is the cultural norm, not an isolated peccadillo. In truth, Labor's leadership has known about this problem since the 1990s but done nothing about it, deferring party reform as too difficult internally and too disruptive electorally."

The scandals within the Health Services Union are a nightmare for the Gillard government, the Labor Party and the union movement - but like three wise monkeys they have chosen to simply ignore "the systemic corruption of the factional system and its trade union affiliates", in the words of a columnist who would know.

As usual, Mark Latham gets it right. And as usual, his history means that although he offers a uniquely candid insider's understanding of Australian politics, his insights will be denigrated by the Labor Party and the press gallery.

Which is a shame. For all his many and ugly flaws, he's the only one from the Labor camp talking about the sort of reform the party needs to survive.

ello, ello, ello .....

Want to do your own investigation on Craig Thomson & just what he was up to at the Health Services Union?

The independent ausit by BDO Kendall, which identified cash advances from Thomson’s credit card totalling $101,533, recently fell off the back of a truck.

For your reading pleasure …

BDO Kendall Audit Report